Earth, the present day, but magic exists... A worn-out concept, even if we modify it and say Earth, but magic used to exist, or perhaps speak in the future tense and mix numerous magically active cycles with less active periods. Or perhaps the supernatural beings mentioned in the game are terribly rare. I have read, seen and tried many recipes. I admit I readily stumbled onto the weak points of games like these. Some would accuse me of doing it deliberately. But accusing someone of deliberate intent is ambiguous: it matters what intention you assume. Then came the standard response: if I do not like it, I should make something better. I think it is wiser to make something different instead.
Make something better. Because a fan considers even a 2% probability rare, since the graph is flat. It never occurs to them that every day we meet numerous people who are in the top 2% in one respect or another. The graph is flat at 1 in 100,000 too. Many people think there is barely any visible difference. Except that the difference is a factor of two thousand. Yet many are not choosing the best out of 100,000 people, but out of several million. The whole point is that someone normally among the best is displaced by any supernatural influence from the circle in which they excelled. In their new circle, they may be the weakest. Of course, you can celebrate becoming undead after being a cool goth.
But I often hear this too: someone with no chance has nothing to lose, and without that there is no reason to speak of anything to fear. This is another system's problem. It is a fixable flaw, and we do fix it. Spotting it requires different skills from creating something better. Different is even harder to create in one respect: we cannot copy even the good solutions. My first decision was that I did not want horror. Precisely because of these traps. But that statement is easily misunderstood.
If you look through the stories on the site, you soon find this ending in one of them:
... If magical power was backed not by forces of good or evil but merely by magic users and people from other worlds, then they too would be varied, with many different values. And who knew what they were capable of? This sort of unknown sounded potentially more dangerous than evil itself. And if she had some talent for this wizardry business, if she could sense energy she could use, that could easily lead to many cases where she did not choose an interesting case, but the case chose her. Vivian did not find that prospect attractive in the slightest.
Magic is unknown to many, and fear of the unknown exists. But picture a scene. Dozens of dead people with terrible wounds. An unusual massacre, immense bloodshed and destruction, and the tough guys never stood much of a chance. Some of the dead are burned, almost burned away. The smell, the blood and the sight of spilled intestines could be enough for a horror story. In reality, a party of fantasy adventurers simply crossed paths with ordinary earthly villains.
For someone who finds that something they tried as a joke actually works, their worldview collapses. They lose many points of reference. It might even give them a longer life. And the whole point is that someone normally among the best is displaced by any supernatural influence from the circle in which they excelled. In the new circle, they are bewildered, weak, inexperienced, and in many respects at the mercy of the source of their new ability. If they stand out because they live a long time, or for another reason, isolation follows.
Yet horror is not the subject. If I had to associate it with a genre, in many respects I would call it fantasy. Not epic, not heroic, but fantasy.
Magic works in this world. The problem, as with so many concepts, is the lack of available magical energy. Almost nobody and nothing on Earth produces it. Visitors from other worlds, whether typical adventurers, demons, angels, spirits, dragons or anything else, may produce magical energy. The surplus they generate may be available. Not to everyone, since different people can use different kinds of energy. Magic is thus rare enough that we need not reinterpret every event because of it.
Passage between worlds is possible, and even the emanations of strong emotions can be felt on the other side. Someone may come from there in response. Through the sacrifice performed by sectarian cultists, the cruelty preceding it, the victim's intimidation and many other details, earthly villains often try to lure something like themselves here. Usually unsuccessfully. And sometimes the result goes beyond mere failure: they unleash a party of adventurers who try to help the victim and may slaughter the evil cultists.
A victim babbling after terror and everything else, a furnished cultist cave, and seven or eight bodies. Of course, a hedonistic pleasure den can also become a gateway, as can many other things. There will not necessarily be a bloodbath, while the visitor from another world faces a small problem in isolation, the lack of a way back, unfamiliar surroundings, reasons to hide and a lack of the knowledge needed to survive locally. Perhaps also intelligence agencies noticing unusual events. And anyone who senses the magical power emanating from them and might want more.
Many kinds of story are possible. Among the beings arriving from many different, alien worlds, some might come from a familiar setting; you can draw inspiration from films, games or anything else. You can build on your existing ideas too. Freedom is easy to provide mechanically, and the world is free in this respect as well. That would be the foundation.